The following is the List of the greats who helped Singh become king. If they had voted by whip, UPA score would have been in the red. But they voted otherwise and most of them slimily giving credence to money and intimidation having worked on them
1. Karnataka
The capital of Ayarams and Gaya rams has shifted from haryana to Karnataka now. Recentlry we saw 3 MLA’s from Congress and some from JDS switching sides to BJp thanks to minning lobby. And now as if for a tit for tat 2 MP’s from BJP cross voted and two abstained plus one JDS cross voted. I feel the JDS is a case of unnecessary overkill almost closing options of aligning with them later. The following is the list of the greats.
H T Sangliana: The former IPS officer and police commissioner of Bangalore who hails from Mizoram stated that he voted for the UPA since he considers “the nation’s interest most important”. Sangliana, a staunch Christian, had originally sought a Congress ticket to contest the 2004 polls, but the presence of Congress veterans like C K Jaffer Sharief from Bangalore North lead to the denial of a ticket to the popular former cop. After the trust vote, Sangliana said he did not expect to continue in the BJP, however, adding that he had struck no deal with the Congress. But, there have been unconfirmed reports that he may contest the next Lok Sabha polls from Mizoram on a Congress ticket.
Manjunath Kunnur: The BJP MP constituency began drifting away from the party nearly a year ago. Not given too much party responsibility, the former Congressman said the final straw came when the BJP brought in outsider Basavaraj Bommai to contest the recent Assembly polls from the Shiggaon constituency in the Dharwad south region. Kunnur said in recent times, Chief Minister B S Yeddyurappa reposed more faith in Bommai than him. He said he did not receive a guarantee of a Lok Sabha ticket for future elections from Advani, Yeddyurappa or Ananth Kumar. “Advani said we could discuss the issue after July 23. Yeddyurappa and Ananth Kumar did not say anything at the dinner in Delhi on July 21. I am basically a Congressman, I will go back to the Congress,” he said.
Manorama Madhwaraj: The Udupi BJP MP’s son Pramod Madhwaraj recently contested the Karnataka Assembly polls on a Congress ticket. The BJP MP herself is reported to have stated in a press note released ahead of the trust vote that there is no guarantee of energy security with the nuclear deal. Though present in the house in the morning, at the time of vote she was absent. .
M Shivanna: The JD(S) MP from tribal Chamarajnagar constituency says he changed his mind and voted in favor of the UPA at the last moment. “I did not want to vote against my conscience though a whip had been issued to vote against the motion. At the last moment I changed my mind,” said the MP who is reported to have received assurances of a Congress ticket for the next elections. “I have faith in my constituency. Let’s see what action is taken,” he said. His constituency is Congress dominated and his action is thus explainable.
D C Srikantappa:BJP MP from Chikmagalur constituency, did not take part in the trust vote in Lok Sabha. He was suffering from spinal problem,ans was strictly advised by his doctors not to undertake travel, the MP’s son Ashok told PTI.
Chief Minister B S Yeddyurappa, who had a telephonic conversation with Srikantappa, had promised to ferry him to Bangalore by a helicopter and later to Delhi by a special flight to facilitate his presence during the crucial voting
Vasudeva Murthy, a physician who is treating Srikantappa, had said then , “He (Srikantappa) should not be made to sit. If such a risk is taken, it would cause further damage to his spinal chord and nerve system”.
Sangliana did not attend BJP meeting before poll and Kunnur was absconding in Delhi before vote and his family had given enough indication that he might cross vote.
2.Andra pradesh
Adikesavulu Naidu: Adikesavulu Naidu is a former Congressman and served as treasurer of the AICC when P V Narasimha Rao was PM. During the same time, he quit the Congress and joined TDP. He was patronised by Naidu, who gave him a ticket to contest from Chittoor in 2004, which he won.
Adikesavulu is also a millionaire liquor baron with extensive interests in Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka.Adikesavalu is a Kapu. He recently remarked that he might support film star Chiranjeevi, a Kapu, if he launches a party. Though other TDP leaders warned Naidu after such comments, Adikesavulu got away with it.According to Yerran Naidu, it seems probable that Adikesavulu wants to quit the TDP, rejoin the Congress and become a Rajya Sabha member. Sources in Hyderabad said Adikesavulu is also worried about his business interests in the state with the TDP out of power. His vote was in validated.
M Jagannath: Jagannath is a medical practitioner and a third-time MP. He is a member of the Indo-China Parliamentary committee. Jagannath was also the chairperson of the Indian Medical Parliamentary Forum till recently. In his first term as MP he was on the Monitoring Committee of Chief Whips and Whips Recommendations.The switching over of Dr M. Jagannath was surprising in the sense that he crossed the floor just before the trust vote.
A. Narendra: TRS rebel MP whad announced well before the vote that he was defecting. he will not suffer the anti defection clause.
3.Maharastra
Haribhau Rathod: Rathod’s defection was a shocker to the party because he is a close confidaant of the BJP’s national general secretary Gopinath Munde and was, at one time, Munde’s private secretary when Munde was Deputy Chief Minister between 1995 and 1999. The fact that Rathod comes from Vidarbha is also a matter of great concern for the party, as it has five MPs from the region.A BJP leader, who did not wish to be named, said, “The Yavatmal constituency has been merged with other LS seats in the delimitation exercise, so Rathod may have felt his political future was not certain. This could be the reason for his abstention.”Rathod, interestingly, was sitting in the Lok Sabha till 6 pm on Tuesday but walked out later, much to the surprise of his other party MPs as well as Shiv Sena MPs from the state.When contacted, Rathod, speaking in a trembling voice, told a Mumbai News paper, “I have chest pain and I am in hospital.” And then disconnected the line.
Tukaram Renge-Patil :Leaders in Parbhani say the 49-year-old MP is miffed with local party leaders and does not enjoy cordial relations with local Sena MLA Sanjay Jadhav.• From the last one and half years, Renge Patil was frequently seen with Congress leaders, claim Shiv Sainiks in Parbhani. • He did not take much interest in local body elections in the district during the last two years. Patil was untraceable and has skipped two crucial meetings the Sena had called for its MPs – one in Mumbai that was presided over by party chief Bal Thackeray on Saturday and the second called in Delhi on Sunday at Parliament House.
4. Gujarat
Somabhai Patel: Suspended BJP MP from Gujarat, Somabhai Patel, on Monday itself declared his support to the UPA government and claimed that “no force or incentive” can bring him back to the party-fold.
“I have been told that my suspension has been revoked. Let me make it clear that I ceased to have any relation with the BJP when I was suspended without even a chance to explain my point,” Patel told PTI in New Delhi. he will be affected by the anti defection law.
Babubhai Katara: BJP MP from Dahod, Babubhai Katara, was suspended for his alleged involvement in a human trafficking case. He will escape the law this time as he is a suspended member. Earlier he had said he will follow the whip but abstained.
5. Uttar pradesh
Brijbhushan Sharan Singh: he joined SP leaving BJP just days before the vote and had made his intentions clear. He is a MP from Balrampur
Samajwadi party: The six SP MPs who cross voted included four rebels (Munawwar Hasan, S.P. Singh Baghel, Rajnarayan Budholia and Jaiprakash Rawat) and two jailbirds (Ateeq Ahmed and Afzal Ansari). No surprises here.
Baleshwar Yadav: The lone member of NLP defied whip by his party and voted for UPA. Yadav, who quit Samajwadi Party earlier, is the NLP MP from Padrauna (UP) Lok Sabha constituency. Amarsingh succeeded in luring him back, it seems.
6.Tamilnadu
MDMK: Two MDMK rebels had defied Whip but had made their intentions well before vote. They are L Ganesan and N Ramachandran.
7. Punjab
Sukhdev Singh Libra: Two-time MP and a trusted man of late SGPC chief Gurcharan Singh Tohra was reportedly lured away from the NDA camp by those Tohra men who are now controlling the Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee. They were reportedly successful in keeping him away.For Sukhdev Singh Libra, it might have been his last term in the Lok Sabha. It is not only delimitation, but also other factors that might have denied him ticket in the coming elections.
8. Bihar
Ramswaroop Prasad : He did not get along well with Nitesh kumar . The JDU MP had made his intentions clear before vote. The MP had dissociated himself from the party at the time of by-election of Islampur Assembly constituency.
9. Lakshadweep
P Koya: the lone MP from Lakshadweep had made his intentions clear by meeting Pm before trust vote
10. Orissa
Harihar Swain : Swain is a known detractor of Patnaik. When contacted, Swain said he voted according to his ‘inner voice’. He was missing in the party organised by Advani before vote.
11. Nagaland
Wangyuh Konyak: The Nagaland People’s Front has asked its lone MP Wangyuh Konyak to vote against the UPA government in the confidence vote, but he had defied the whip. NPF was with UPA for long but it’s government was dismissed from nagaland by Center and hence the party had issued such a whip, which the MP defied.
12. Madhya pradesh
Chandrabhan singh: BJP MP from Madhya Pradesh Chandra Bhan Singh’s both houses at Damoh and Jabalpur were attacked by protesting partymen on Tuesday night. Protesters carried out rampage at both places and burned his effigy. He is the MP from Damoh. He had abstained citing health reasons. Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chauhan lashed out at Singh for betraying the BJP, saying that health was not the reason why he didn’t vote.
“His family members are saying that he was not well, but it is a matter of investigation and I think that there is something more to his abstension,” Shivraj Singh Chauhan said.
13. Haryana
Kuldeep Bishnoi: Bishnoi had floated his own political outfit, the Haryana Janhit Congress, in December last year. He is the son of Bhajan Lal and is a rebel Congress MP from Bhiwani
14. Others
MNF snapped ties with NDA in 2007 and abstained in the vote. Trinamool congress was with NDA, till recently but abstained .
Summary of Defections
1. BJP- 8 plus one for genuine reasons.
2. SP- 6
3. TDP: 2
4.JDU:2
5. MDMK:2
6.Shivsena-1
7. Akali Dal- 1
8. BJD-1
9. NLP:1
10.NPF:1
11.JDS:1
12.TRS:1
13. Congress:1
Total: 29 [ 28 plus one genuine]
*No one from Left parties and BSP cross voted or abstained.
*List of abstentions
TC-1[Mamta]
MNF-1[Vanlalzawma]
Akalidal-1[Sukhdev Singh Libra ]
BJD-1[Swain]
BJP-5[Katara, Manorama, D C Srikantappa,Harisingh Rathod, Chandrabhan singh]
JDU-1[P.Koya]
TDP-1[D K Audikesavulu].
We had predicted 30-40 deserters. the actual is 29. one congress MP from Haryana changed his mind in last moment. And surprisingly no defections from BSP and Congress.
The Congress game plan is very clear. Not only to get numbers but wound all parties of NDA be it even by one defection and also those of UNPA. May be the overkill is because of surprisingly no defections from their ranks. It clearly shows BJP did not try hard. For the same ‘delimitation’ could have made them lure some of the Congress probables. Congress should Thank them for this. May be Maya has a point here.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Leave a comment »
You must be logged in to post a comment.